Interview with USC’s Morgan Polikoff reveals new poll data and insights into the ‘Purple Classroom’

A recent study carried out by a couple of researchers at the University of Southern California revealed broad consensus among Americans on the importance of public education. Nonetheless, the study highlighted partisan divisions on what subjects schools should teach and at which grade levels. The survey participants expressed support for parental rights conceptually but seemed to overlook the practical challenges of granting exemptions from specific lessons to individual students.

The latest findings, in line with Anna Saavedra and Morgan Polikoff’s 2022 research, underscore the ideological chasm fueling the ongoing culture wars. The study delved into Americans’ perceptions of the content taught in schools. To bridge the apparent disconnect, the researchers sought insights from a representative sample of 4,000 households in September and October 2023. The participants were presented with various hypothetical classroom scenarios involving race, LGBTQ topics, and opt-out options, correlating their responses with broader education beliefs.

Close to 90% of respondents emphasized the significance of teaching fundamental academic skills within public education. While the majority agreed on the importance of safeguarding democracy, government education, and delivering free education, there were diverging views on allocation priorities. Approximately three-fourths favored enhancing public education quality through increased funding over subsidizing private schooling for low-income children.

However, disparities emerged on ideological grounds regarding certain educational imperatives. For instance, instilling the value of embracing differences resonated more with 74% of Democrats compared to 35% of Republicans. Similarly, while nearly all respondents endorsed teaching equality irrespective of skin color, the acceptance of discussing policies favoring white Americans notably varied, with just 14% of Republicans supportive compared to 46% of Democrats.

The starkest contrasts surfaced when examining LGBTQ topics. Democratic inclinations leaned heavily toward affirming high school instruction on LGBTQ matters, ranging from 80% to 86% under varying scenarios, but plummeted to 40% to 50% for younger students. In contrast, Republican comfort levels decreased considerably, with support for LGBTQ content dropping below 40% at the high school level and below 10% at elementary grades.

Throughout a recent interview, Polikoff emphasized the critical need for substantive discussions to chart the future course for education in the United States.

—

I found that commencing the analysis with public education backing was instrumental to provide a solid foundation for analyzing responses to specific policy questions. We posed a broad query on education’s objectives, asking respondents to prioritize essential aspects of schooling. Unsurprisingly, most participants instinctively prioritized imparting core literacy and numeracy skills. Nevertheless, a notable exception was identified concerning the emphasis on teaching the importance of embracing diversity.

This particular aspect stood out as the most distinct predictor influencing respondents’ opinions on subsequent education-related issues.

—

Our investigation revealed surprising alignment in attitudes toward market dynamics and educational choice, contrasting with the anticipated partisan rifts. The majority favored investing public funds in public schools, with a significant percentage acknowledging the positive impacts of competition on enhancing public school quality and resource utilization. The shallow partisan divide on these topics contradicts the conventional notions, primarily driven by the Republican emphasis on educational choice.

While Republicans generally exhibit higher support for choice policies, the discrepancies are not as substantial due to existing overlap in ideological underpinnings among Democrats and Republicans. School choice discourse represents a focal point for Republican policymakers, but its resonance with ordinary voters remains moderate. The intricate interplay between neighborhood schooling, individual preferences, and overarching support for public education underscores the nuanced nature of educational policymaking.

By and large, the ideological contours of the education landscape reveal intricate pathways, necessitating deliberate conversations to sculpt a coherent vision for educational reforms.

—