High Expectations and Major Demands at Success Academy Schools

Among the first graders of Evelyn Gonzalez, they sit attentively on the rug, displaying good posture, hands neatly folded in their laps. They observe the teacher closely with quiet focus.

“Reading aloud from the easel pad, Gonzalez shares a word problem: ‘Katey had 35 stickers.’ Co-teacher Sherron Davis supervises vigilantly, maintaining discipline by alerting fidgeting or whispering students. The problem involves placing five stickers on each page of a sticker book, challenging the students to determine the number of pages Katey used for her stickers.”

Success Academy schools, like the one where Gonzalez teaches, demand high academic standards from young students by enforcing strict disciplinary measures such as good posture and eye contact with the teacher. This charter network based in New York City surpasses district schools in academic performance metrics like state tests, graduation rates, and college acceptance.

At Success Academy, teachers believe in their approach, but critics argue that the schools prioritize test prep over broad knowledge and counsel out students who may affect the network’s stellar academic results. Opponents also criticize the harsh and compliance-based disciplinary practices.

Despite the controversy, over 16,000 families vied for roughly 3,200 spots at Success Academy schools this academic year, showcasing the network’s appeal as it offers unique educational opportunities seen as unattainable in local district schools.

In a 2019 op-ed, Washington Post columnist Jay Matthews encapsulated the dual reputation of Success Academy as both the highest-performing and most criticized educational institution in New York and beyond.

Founder Eva Moskowitz remains resolute in the face of critics, emphasizing the joy and engagement present in Success schools and dispelling notions that they solely focus on test preparation, highlighting a holistic education approach that extends beyond exams and includes various enriching activities.

While Success schools may not suit everyone, they offer a highly structured and rigorous educational experience for those willing to invest the time and resources, providing unique opportunities to families and students from underserved communities.

The Strategy in Action

In her math lesson, Evelyn Gonzalez demonstrates the problem-solving strategy called the “plan of attack” to her first-grade students, emphasizing the systematic approach to deciphering complex word problems. The methodology encourages students to comprehend problems thoroughly before executing solutions.

“Understanding the story behind the numbers is vital in math,” explains Liu, as he guides eighth-grade students through a complex algebraic problem, fostering a culture where students focus on problem analysis before numerical calculations.

As students engage in challenging math tasks, they exhibit discipline and intellectual rigor, reflecting the school’s commitment to academic seriousness and structured learning environments.

Success Academy prioritizes standardized curricula, lesson planning, and classroom management, aiming to streamline educational processes to enhance teaching effectiveness.

An Environment of Predictability

Success Academy emphasizes intense behavioral standards and consistent routines to maintain student discipline and promote a sense of security, as predictable environments facilitate better academic outcomes.

By enforcing clear expectations and routines, even young students quickly adapt to school norms and responsibilities, ultimately fostering a conducive learning environment.

Consistency in routines and accountability is key at Success Academy, ensuring student success by establishing clear expectations and promoting disciplined behaviors.

Fostering a Love for Learning

Success Academy aims to instill a love for learning in its students, beginning with warm, welcoming interactions with staff and promoting intellectual engagement through daily reading requirements.

Every child is encouraged to read daily as part of the educational experience, emphasizing the importance of intellectual curiosity and literacy development.

Success Academy’s rigorous academic standards reflect the belief that children are capable of achieving high levels of academic success when challenged and supported appropriately.

Success Academy’s high expectations and accountability underscore the commitment to empowering students from diverse backgrounds to excel and pursue their aspirations, emphasizing the importance of academic excellence and college readiness.

The Involvement of Parents

Parental involvement is a crucial component at Success Academy, with families expected to adhere to strict guidelines and support their child’s education, contributing to a collaborative and highly structured educational environment.

While Success Academy places significant demands on parents, the school rejects the notion that their expectations are excessive, as they believe in the essential role of parental involvement in a child’s educational journey.

Despite challenges, Success Academy accommodates students from various backgrounds, providing necessary support and resources to ensure each child’s success within a structured and disciplined educational setting.