Funding Gaps in Large Metro School Districts: A Closer Look

According to the latest Bellwether report, taking decisive action on multiple fronts is crucial to addressing the local revenue gaps between affluent and less wealthy school districts in neighboring areas. It underscores the importance of implementing changes to state funding formulas to incorporate a sufficient base amount per student, particularly for students in poverty or requiring additional support. 

The report also emphasizes the need for local leaders to engage in discussions and implement solutions that can reduce these disparities. Suggestions include district consolidations, setting caps on local revenue, and policies ensuring equity in revenue generation for districts with similar tax rates.

An analysis conducted by Bellwether focused on 123 major metropolitan areas across 38 states revealed significant funding gaps among districts within the same region. Wealthier districts tend to have higher local funding per student due to economic segregation, exacerbating disparities. Moreover, variations in taxable property wealth enable affluent districts to raise more revenue compared to less wealthy ones with lower tax rates.

In areas like Southwest Connecticut, income disparities are stark, with affluent districts spending significantly more per pupil compared to less privileged districts. For instance, the most affluent districts have an average revenue of $28,899 per pupil, while less wealthy districts receive an average of $17,351 per pupil.

The report warns that maintaining the current policy framework will perpetuate advantages for affluent communities in public school systems. Notably, the disparity in funding distribution remains a prevailing concern that needs urgent attention.

The Bellwether study provides several key figures to highlight the funding dynamics:

By the numbers
The proportion of public school students residing in major metro areas with over five districts, contributing to funding disparities.
$26 billion
The additional state funding required annually to bridge the funding gap among districts within the metro areas studied.
The percentage of students attending traditional public schools in large metro areas with at least 50,000 public school students.
4.8 million
The student enrollment in 756 metro-area school districts classified as “economic elite” due to higher income levels and property wealth.
19.4 million
The number of students attending 2,837 metro-area school districts categorized as “middle class majority.”
3.6 million
The students in 545 metro-area districts labeled “opportunity outsider” due to lower income and property wealth.
The average state and local revenue per pupil for opportunity outsider districts in the Philadelphia metro area, compared to economic elite districts with $21,402 per pupil.
The difference in average state and local revenue per pupil between economic elite ($11,493) and opportunity outsider districts ($11,725) in the Houston metro area. Bellwether attributes the narrower gap to mechanisms limiting local tax generation, allowing state revenue to offset disparities.

Other articles

Post Image
New Administrators’ Entry Plan

After years of diligent preparation for a school leadership role—participating i …

Read More
Post Image
Cell phone policies in NYC schools highlight difficulties of implementing statewide ban.

Forest Hills High School’s cell phone policy appears straightforward on th …

Read More
Post Image
Michigan school districts must allocate federal stimulus funds before deadline

Michigan is sitting on billions of dollars in COVID-19 federal funding earmarked …

Read More